Return rate

An online shop ships 20,000 items in a month, and 1,600 of them come back. That is eight in every hundred. The share of what you sold that the customer sends back is called the return rate.

How the return rate is calculated

Take the number of returns in a period, divide by the number of items shipped in the same period, and multiply by 100. Three decisions determine what the answer means.

The first is the unit: items, orders or value. Items is the usual choice and the only one the warehouse can act on directly. Value is the finance choice, because it separates a returned coat from a returned pair of socks.

The second is the period. A return arriving today belongs to a sale made weeks earlier. Dividing this month's returns by this month's sales is only safe when sales run flat. In a month when sales doubled, that calculation makes the return rate look as if it had halved.

The third is what counts. Customer rejections, transport damage, your own picking errors and unsold goods a retailer sends back are four different problems. Count them all, but mark them, or you average away exactly the part you can fix.

There is no good number

In clothing, where customers deliberately order two sizes and send one back, a rate that would be an emergency for an industrial distributor is simply how the category works. For spare parts or groceries almost nothing should come back. There is no cross-industry number worth measuring yourself against.

Compare with your own previous year instead, and then by product group. The shop average is a blend; the information sits in the two or three groups that run far above it, and that is usually a sizing problem, a photo problem or a packaging problem rather than a returns problem.

Worked example

Of the 20,000 items that left the building in the month, 1,600 came back: 1,600 divided by 20,000 is 0.08, so the return rate was eight per cent.

Now look at what arrived. Of those 1,600 items, 1,180 went straight back into sellable stock, 300 needed repacking or light refurbishing, and 120 could no longer be sold. So eight per cent came back, but only six per cent of what was shipped returned at full value. If your report shows one figure while your stock planning works from the other, the gap turns into dead stock. The figures here are an example.

What moves the number

  • What the customer saw before buying. Size guides, measurements, photos of the real item. More returns are decided on the product page than anywhere in the warehouse.
  • Picking errors. A wrong item is a return you created yourself. This is the part of the rate that picking accuracy decides directly.
  • Transport damage and packaging. Items that arrive dented go back. Carton size and void fill are therefore a returns lever, not just a cost line.
  • Delivery time. A parcel that arrives after the occasion it was bought for comes back, whatever the item.
  • The policy. Free returns raise the rate and often repeat purchases with it. Charging for returns lowers the rate and does something else to the customer, which this figure will not show you.
  • How fast you process. Slow returns handling does not change the rate, but it decides how much of the returned stock is still worth anything when it reaches the shelf.

Frequently asked questions

Items, orders or value?

All three are used and they give different answers. Items is the most common and the easiest to act on in the warehouse. Value matters most to finance, because a returned coat and a returned pair of socks are not the same event.

How do you handle the time lag?

A return that arrives in March belongs to a sale from February or January. Dividing this month's returns by this month's sales is quick and wrong as soon as sales swing hard. Tying returns back to the month of sale is slower and worth the effort.

Is a lower return rate always better?

Not on its own. A rate that falls because you tightened the returns policy shows up later as fewer repeat purchases. A rate that falls because the product photos improved is a real gain. The figure does not tell you which of the two happened.

Do picking errors count as returns?

Count them, and mark them separately. A return you caused by sending the wrong item is a cost you control, and burying it in the overall rate means nobody looks for it.

Ready to see BizBloqs on your own process?

Book a demo and we will walk your warehouse and order flow end to end — inbound, storage, picking, shipping, returns — and tell you honestly what BizBloqs would change.

Two questions about your own operation

Book a demo