First time right
Out of 1,000 orders in a day, 940 go from the pick list to the carrier without anyone touching them twice. Sixty ask for something to be done again: a line picked a second time, a label reprinted, a carton opened and repacked. The share that needs no second attempt is called first time right, also written right first time.
How to calculate first time right
Take the number of orders finished without rework, divide it by the total number of orders and multiply by one hundred. The same sum works for order lines, for receipts and for putaway tasks, and each one answers a different question.
The difficulty is not the arithmetic. It is that rework is usually invisible. A packer who spots the wrong item, walks back down the aisle, swaps it and says nothing has just done rework that no system recorded. Until that second attempt is recorded, the figure measures how well you record, not how often things go wrong, and a suspiciously good figure is the normal first result.
So the honest order of work is this: give the team a way to record a correction in a single action, expect the figure to fall for a month, and treat the fall as the moment the measurement starts to work.
There is no good number
A warehouse that ships one product in one carton size has very little to redo. A warehouse where every retailer wants its own labels, its own paperwork and its own pallet build has a great deal. The two figures cannot be compared, and neither says which warehouse is better run.
What the figure is for is the trend, and above all what the rework is made of. Sixty reworked orders of which fifty are wrong picks point to a problem at the pick location. Sixty of which fifty are reprinted labels point to a printer problem, and no amount of picker training will change that.
In practice
Of the 60 orders reworked that day, 34 were a wrong or short pick found at the packing station, 14 were a label or document reprinted, 9 were repacked into a different carton, and 3 waited while a customer-specific form was found. Divide 940 by 1,000 and you get 0.94: first time right was 94 percent.
A reworked order costs roughly twice the handling of a clean one, which is where this figure meets the cost per order line. The numbers here are an illustration, not a benchmark.
What moves the number
- Scanning at the workstation. Checking against a barcode at the pick location and again at the packing station stops the largest category before it becomes rework.
- Printers and labels. Unglamorous, and often at the top of the list. A smeared label, a printer that jams at volume or label stock loaded in the wrong tray creates rework all day.
- Packing rules. If the packer chooses the carton, some will be wrong. If the system chooses and the carton file is out of date, every one will be.
- Customer-specific paperwork. Every exception a salesperson agrees is a chance for a second attempt. The exceptions are worth having; leaving them undocumented is not.
- How rework is recorded. Counter-intuitively, recording it better makes the figure worse and the warehouse better. Say so before the first report reaches the table.
- New and temporary staff. The pattern is the same as for picking accuracy: rework clusters around people who do not yet know the building.
Frequently asked questions
What counts as rework?
Any second attempt at a task that should have needed one: a line picked again, a label reprinted, a carton opened and repacked, a document chased, a pallet rebuilt. If someone touched it twice, it was not right first time.
Why is our figure suspiciously high?
Almost always because rework is not recorded. In most warehouses small problems are fixed informally at the packing station and nothing reaches the system. Until the second attempt is recorded, the figure measures your recording, not your work.
Should we measure orders, lines or receipts?
All three are worth measuring, separately. Outbound orders give the usual headline. Receipts are often more telling, because rework at the dock is invisible to the customer and costly to you.
How is it different from picking accuracy?
Picking accuracy asks whether the pick was correct. First time right asks whether anything had to be redone, including labels, paperwork, packing and loading. It is the wider figure, and the one that follows lost hours.
Further reading
Ready to see BizBloqs on your own process?
Book a demo and we will walk your warehouse and order flow end to end — inbound, storage, picking, shipping, returns — and tell you honestly what BizBloqs would change.
Two questions about your own operation
How many of your articles sit in a pick location they empty less than once a month?
Part one: Laying out a warehouse does not start with the racking
After your last integration, how many systems hold a stock quantity for the same item? Name them.